Hostages
Episode 1: Pilot
By: Carlos Uribe
Hostages is a
television show about a doctor's family who is taken hostage when she
has to operate on the President. I will be reviewing this show
weekly.
Spoilers
Ahoy!
The idea behind Hostages is a complicated one. I'm not talking about
a viewer understanding the premise of the show. It might be a little
tough to actually explain to someone in a couple sentences what the
show is about but it's not beyond comprehension. No, I'm talking
about how long the premise can actually drive the narrative before it
becomes ridiculous, idiotic, and/or stale. There's only so long that
a family can be held hostage before the writers run out of ideas to
actually make it work and believable. This presents Hostages with a
weird conundrum going forward: how will the series work in the
long-term? The behind-the-scenes interviews and article pieces hint
that this first season will be completely resolved by the end. It
will largely be self-contained and act as a mini-series. The second
season will hit the reset button. It'll have a completely new
narrative with the same characters. This hopefully suggests that the
title “Hostages” becomes more metaphoric than literal since I
don't think viewers are really going to appreciate the same family
being taken hostage more than once. So we can take it that the
mythical second season will actually have a different premise that
somehow builds on the original. Okay, so the long-term survivability
of the premise being able to drive the narrative is kind-of solved.
You still get into the point that this first season is going to have
fifteen episodes. A whole season that takes place over the course of
two weeks isn't impossible to do but I'm currently doubtful if
Hostages, in particular, can pull it off. Let's assume they do have a
plan: this still means they have to come up with what every episode
is going to be about. Fifteen episodes is a pretty big order and I
wouldn't be surprised if it stretches the premise to it's limits.
This worry about how the series will work as it goes along is a
strong one but it shouldn't be enough to not check the pilot out.
After all, first the series has to survive before we have to worry
about the how. First we have to deal with the immediate problems.
The pilot has a lot of problems going forward. The reason that I
doubt that Hostages can actually carry out the first season over two
weeks is a matter of tension. Tension is integral to any series but
it's the lifeblood to a series like Hostages. You need to feel like
you have been taken hostage with the family. There needs to be a
level of uncertainty that make you hold your breath. For all the flak
that Homeland has gotten, it's tense episodes are unlike anything on
television. Hostages should be a show where any wrong move could end
up disastrously wrong for the characters. Where you don't know if
their going to survive or how they'll be able to live two weeks under
constant guard. These are people with guns that are taking over their
lives. They have lost a lot of their freedom. The very existence of a
hostage should be sufficient to instantly create a lot of tension.
It's a bit shocking that Hostages completely fails at setting up any
tension. I'm not entirely sure why that is but I think it has to do
with the execution. The pilot opens up to the family sitting down in
front of the coach. They look a bit worried but we soon realize that
men with guns are surrounding them. It's an incredibly tense idea. In
execution? It's more comical than anything. The pilot never actually
makes you feel like the family is in danger. That's partly because of
them having to survive the two weeks in order for the first season to
work. It's also partly in scenes where one of the men in guns tries
to comfort the son by showing him that the dog is still alive. Like
the head hostage taker notes, the family is supposed to fear the
hostage takers. They don't have to be liked by the family. In a weird
sense, it's a bit odd when the pilot basically admits it made a
stupid move. In showing that the dog is still alive, the pilot
betrays any sense that the family is in any actual danger. Once that
element of danger is removed, everything becomes melodramatic. There
is no tension. So the question should be how can Hostages keep the
tension going for fifteen episodes but rather it's how can Hostages
work when it can't even get the tension going in the first place? The
fact that I have to ask the wrong question is likely why Hostages is
ultimately doomed: it's lifeblood of tension isn't there.
The main protagonist of Hostages is Dr. Ellie Sanders. She's a
well-respected doctor who was chosen to operate on the President of
the United States. This is a pretty big honor even if the surgery is
rather routine. Of course, Hostages messes up there. If the President
needed the surgery because he only has a limited time to live then
the tension builds. Anyways, Dr. Sanders is a tough lady who tries to
act that operating on the President is no big deal. The humble doctor
finds her life thrown upside down when her family gets taken hostage.
Dr. Sanders is told she has to kill the President or her family will
be killed. She's the kind of character who subversively finds way to
resist her captors which at least gives her enough agency to keep the
narrative flowing. The choice presented to her is a pretty big one
with major consequences either ways. The stakes are high for her. At
the same time, the tension isn't there because the stakes are too
high. Is she actually going to kill the President? She's the heroine
and this is network television. I mean, come on, she's the only
family member that doesn't have a secret exposed in the pilot. I
doubt that she'll actually be forced to end the President's life. Is
she going to allow her family to be killed? That sound you hear is me
laughing at the very idea. I'll be shocked if a single family member
ends up dead. The hostage takers didn't even kill their dog. So the
stakes might be high but it's a bit difficult to buy into them. Toni
Collette does a great job but the role is so trite that she makes for
a very standard protagonist. If perhaps the stakes had been higher
and she herself had a secret then maybe she would work better in
creating tension.
The rest of the characters are just as troublesome. The antagonist is
Duncan Carlisle. He's an FBI agent whose motivation is that he wants
to help his family. It's implied his wife's health is being held
hostage (GET IT? LOOK AT THE LEVELS OF HOSTAGE-TAKING) by someone in
the White House. He's being forced into taking the family hostage. I
like the levels of grey and it helps make Duncan be more compelling
than Sanders. At the same time, it also basically means he's going to
be an anti-hero. I don't expect this anti-hero to be an actual threat
to our family which he kind of needed to be. His team is made up of
three members that are largely forgettable. There's one who wants to
be liked by the son, a girl who is all tough, and a black one. I
don't remember their names. As for the Sanders family? The dad is a
typical husband who cheats on his wife. I do think it's a bit odd
that when the hostage takers threatened to kill his whole family, he
still told his wife to resist their instructions to kill the
President. They threaten to expose his affair? All of a sudden, he
wants her to do what they ask. The guy's priorities are out of wack.
What? He doesn't care if his kids die as long as his wife thinks he
was an honorable man? His daughter, Morgan, is pregnant from her
secret boyfriend. Typical teen drama. The son, Jake, owes money to a
drug dealer. Oh great, more typical teen family. There is nothing
that makes the Sanders family interesting or stand out. At this
point, the most compelling character is Duncan but his levels of grey
undermines the show because it means he's no real threat. Which means
there is no tension.
Alas, there are a lot of problems with Hostages. The question of how
long the premise can keep going is one we shouldn't be asking because
it's doubtful the series will last long enough for us to find out.
The problem with Hostages is there is no tension in it's execution or
writing. The main protagonist is offered an interesting choice but
she's a typical network heroine that will find a way to save her
family without killing the President. The anti-hero Duncan might be a
compelling character but his existence undermines the tension that's
already there. It might have been better to reveal details about his
life after the pilot so we gain a greater understanding of his
motives after we already feel that he's a threat. The hostage-takers
are all largely forgettable while the Sanders family is to typical to
really be interesting. Hostages isn't a completely terrible show but
it has many problems that it needs to solve before we can even talk
about it's future.
Other
Notes:
I don't know but I would think that when a doctor is chosen to
operate on the President, the doctor gets a secret security
attachment to ensure that something like this doesn't happen. I could
be wrong.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Please be respectful of people's opinions. Remember these reviews are MY opinion and you may disagree with them. These are just TV shows.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.