Castle
Episode 23: The Human
Factor
By: Carlos Uribe
Castle
is a show about a mystery writer who helps his lover solve crimes.
Spoilers
Ahoy!
Castle
is not always a very realistic show. This really shouldn't come as a
surprise. After all, the premise of this show is that a worldwide
best-selling author would help the police solve crimes. He might have
his reasons (love of mystery and love of Beckett) but it's doubtful
that he would have been allowed to shadow a police detective for over
a hundred cases in the real world. The whole point of fiction is
willing to suspend your disbelief for the sake of the story. The show
has been able to get away with a lot over the years but sometimes I
must question the credibility of a case. Take this week's
investigation: it's over a drone strike that killed a prominent
government critic. Federal agents quickly show up at the crime scene
and start gathering all evidence. They take the car away and don't
let CSU get their hands on the body. They threaten to arrest any cop
who gets in the way of their investigation and basically take it
over. In the real world, this would be the end for any local
detective to help out on the case. They would cede jurisdiction over
and go to the crimes that they are supposed to solve. In the world of
Castle, this possibility doesn't even exist. Beckett treats this case
like it's always her and she's determined to solve it no matter what.
It's a sign of her desire to put away criminals but it's not her
case. When the federal agents came, it was no longer her job to
investigate. The series might be about a group of cops but it has
very little respect for rules or laws. Esposito has already been
shown to be willing to break the law or regulations in order to get
the desired effects. Beckett and Castle are likewise willing to bend
the rules to catch the killer. There's a moment where Beckett notes
they can't enter a person's property because of a gate but Castle's
advice is to pretend to not see the signs. Really? I don't think that
would hold up in court. I don't think I'll every understand this
show's flippant disregard for the legal system.
I'll
admit that, while I had to accept that Beckett would treat this
investigation as her own, the set-up of the case was pretty
intriguing. It looked a lot like a cover-up which had me wondering
what exactly happened. It turns out this wasn't a cover-up but a
legitimate investigation by a special federal law enforcement branch.
They simply didn't want anybody else getting involved since they
wanted to keep the investigation as neutral as possible considering
how the target was on the watch-list of other federal agencies and
the New York City Counter-terrorism Unit. Beckett is only able to get
them to co-operate with her when she arrests the lead agent and
basically refuses to free him until he tells he everything she knows.
They're able to figure out that the government played no role in the
murder because the drone was hacked. The one person they believe is
capable of hacking the drones and having the software to drive them
turns out to be innocent. He's a bit crazy because he believes that
allowing the government to have drones will allow it to control the
lives of citizens through fear. He does reveal that someone does have
the code and it turns out to be the son of the victim. The son wasn't
happy because his dad made his life miserable, never spent any time
with them, and had an affair. He had motive and the opportunity so he
took it. The kid gets arrested and the case is solved because of our
detectives. The son as the killer felt like a sudden move by the
writers. It might be because the kid couldn't sell the anger he was
supposed to have but it felt like he was chosen because the other
suspects were red herrings and the show needed a real killer. So it
simply chose at random. I'm not sure but more could have been done to
paint him convincingly as the killer.
Beckett
was able to solve the case and this impresses the federal agent. The
agent works for an investigation group right under the Attorney
General. He thinks that Beckett is too good to be just a homicide
detective and that she would want cases with higher stakes. He
decides to offer her a job. She has to interview for it but there's
no doubt she would get it if she applied. She decides to think about
it and then later lies to Castle when he asks her what the agent
talked to her about. The question we're supposed to be asking is
whether or not Beckett will accept the job offer. I sincerely doubt
it. This is an offer that's exclusive to Beckett which means Castle
wouldn't be able to tag along. Guess whose name is the title of the
show? Castle. If she accepts this job then it would basically break
the structure of the show. He's investigating crimes because he's in
love with her and their rapport makes him good at it. Sure, he could
stick with Esposito and Javier but it just wouldn't be the same. No
offense to those two characters but they're not developed enough that
the show would be able work with just the three of them while Beckett
is in a federal agency. It's not like Castle can just follow her and
if he could then what would happen to Esposito and Javier? This is
the kind of job offer that comes along to threaten to disrupt the
status quo. She might even accept it as a small twist that the
writers later find a way to get out of. This is a decision that she
supposedly grapples with in the season finale but it's hard to really
care when you know that it doesn't matter. For the sake of the show's
survival, there's no way the show is going to permanently have her
join a federal agency.
The
Human Factor is largely a good episode of Castle. It's flippant
disregard to laws and rules become apparent this episode but the case
is interesting enough for it to be forgiven. The killer felt forced
rather than organic, seemingly picked because the writers had run out
of characters. The job offer towards Beckett at the end would disrupt
the status quo too much to really be an effective build-up to the
finale. The episode might have it's flaws but it was an entertaining
one.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Please be respectful of people's opinions. Remember these reviews are MY opinion and you may disagree with them. These are just TV shows.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.