1600 Penn
Episode 5:
Frosting/Nixon
By: Carlos Uribe
1600
Penn is a show about a normal family that happens to reside in the
White House.
Spoilers
Ahoy!
One
of the most annoying aspects about a new comedy is that it relies too
much on it's premise. It makes sense that a comedy about the first
family would create situations that arise from that status. The
problem is that these situations are predictable, lame, or both. It
might be because the characters have yet to be properly defined and
developed but it's also because the ideas simply aren't working in
execution. I'm sure that the idea of having a social service agent
act as a therapist might have been a good one on paper but it's not
funny. This is an episode that relies a little bit too much on it's
premise in an effort to try and create comedic situations but it
fails to work because the jokes all fall flat. 1600 Penn continues to
have a lot of promise but there's many problems that hold it down
that are detrimental to the show's humor. Weak characters, plot ideas
that go nowhere, lazy jokes, and it's premise are all holding it
down. These are problems many comedies might face in the early days
but they can be so frustrating when a show has all of them. The way
the ratings are going, 1600 Penn is not going to survive but it's
difficult to grieve the passing of a show that fails to be inspired
by it's own premise. I believe I've talked enough about how weak the
characters are but I think it's time to explore how the premise is
holding it down.
The
idea that Skip is easily swayed by political opinions actually makes
sense for the character. In this episode, he gets caught between his
father's policies and the protesters that oppose them. It might make
sense for the character but the show failed to really do anything
with the idea. The jokes are largely what you would expect and the
plot is as predictable as possible. The writers have no fresh
perspective to offer an idea that has been used in situational
comedies in the past. It's this kind of uninspired and lazy writing
that is starting to make 1600 Penn unwatchable. There are a couple of
things the show could have done with this plot. The first is to use
it to reveal more about the President's character. When all is said
and done, we didn't learn a single thing about him. When he claims to
have gotten through to Skip, we don't know what that means to him.
The second thing it could have done is offer a unique view on the
partisan divide between the political spectrum. It tried to do this
but it never really works as the protesters aren't developed and the
issue they're fighting over is guaranteed to not offend the mass
majority of Americans. If it wants to comment on the political
differences between people and how the President can unite groups
against his policies, then it could have done it much more
effectively by actually picking a contentious issue or at least
trying to show what this issue meant to the President. There was no
emotional connection to the issue so therefore it felt empty and the
President felt like he didn't really have any passion.
One
of the most annoying premises is to take student elections as
seriously as real ones. There is a usual predictable joke where
polling information comes in. It's just something I've seen before
and I've gotten tired of it. 1600 Penn tackling this plot could
provide the fresh air to make it interesting again. To it's credit,
it does steer away from having demographic polling but it doesn't
really offer anything fresh. It tries to use the plot to develop the
relationship between Emily and Xander but there's a problem with
this. Their weak characterization aside, the show doesn't really
commit to their relationship being the core of the story. The
election plot isn't really even resolved by Emily, Xander or both but
by Marigold. This is meant to show that she does stick up for her
brother even if he annoys her but it doesn't work. This plot could
have worked better if it had picked it's core: the Xander-Emily
relationship or the bond Marigold has with her brother. I would have
picked the second as maybe the show could have then avoided the
obvious pitfalls in taking the student elections way more seriously
than in real life.
The
final plot is with Becca. She realizes that all of her friends are
having successful lives but she's not doing anything as she's
pregnant. She starts to use a secret service agent as a therapist.
This idea could have been good but there's a couple problems. The
first is that the show thinks that the idea by itself is the
punchline. That is like setting up a joke only to stop telling it
because you think that the set-up is funny by itself. The second
problem is that it doesn't dedicate itself to it. As soon as the
viewers realize the set-up of the show, it changes gears by having
Becca's insecurities kicking in on why the agent doesn't talk back to
her. This isn't the case as the agent is an even bigger mess than
Becca and the plot is slowly closed out without any real resolution.
Which is ultimately the biggest failure of the plot: it doesn't
really mean anything. Becca doesn't really grow as a human being nor
do we find out anything new about her.
Frosting/Nixon
is an episode that proves how non-committal this show is or how lazy
it is when it does follow through with an idea. I'm not saying the
show should abandon it's premise but it should be using it to develop
the characters. It could have used Skip's plot to develop the
President more along with establishing his belief system. It could
have used the election plot to develop the bond between Xander and
Marigold or Xander and Emily. It could have stuck with the Becca plot
to reveal something we didn't already know. Frosting/Nixon is an
episode that proves that 1600 Penn is all situation but with little
regard to character without realizing that character is what makes
the situations work comically and emotionally.
Other Notes:
The
show seems to have settled on Xander's personality trait: a crazy
radical.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Please be respectful of people's opinions. Remember these reviews are MY opinion and you may disagree with them. These are just TV shows.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.